Overhaul of Fitzgibbon Cup referees sorely needed says DCU manager

It was the case of two very contrasting years for the DCU hurling club. They began their campaign in early October with an outstanding series of victories, the highlight being a stirring comeback to beat UCD in the local derby by one goal.

Drawn in a very tough group for Fitzgibbon, including tournament favorites CIT, expectations were that DCU could progress to the knockout stages. This was not to be. DCU managed only one win and failed to qualify from their group. Manager Nick Weir was very disappointed given the effort put in leading up to the championship.

“The effort from the lads this year was immense. Training was superb and the facilities here at DCU catered to our every need. The results don’t’ reflect on our positivity and work rate leading up to championship.”

The team never really recovered after a disappointing result in their opening game against CIT. In a match surrounded by controversies over an early sending off of Peter Carroll, DCU lost by an eye watering 1-6 to 0-17.

With this deflating loss and with the now absent Carroll, DCU succumbed to a strong UCD outfit, losing by a margin of 2-16 to 1-14. The chance of getting out of the group was now truly over but the team pulled themselves together in order to avoid the embarrassment of the wooden spoon and defeated St. Pat’s in their final game with a score of 1-20 to 0-11.

The quality of the Fitzgibbon competition was apparent this year. Inter-county stars littered every team sheet and high profile mangers and trainers prowled the sidelines. Weir put DCU’s failures down to the lack of depth in the squad.

“Other teams have a panel of 20-23 players to call on that are of inter-county level. For us this year, I would put that number at 15-16 players”

With this quality and development on display, there must be more done in order for the competition to maintain its credibility. Once again this year the eligibility of certain players has come into question. I.T Carlow were thrown out only to be re-instated after an appeal.

The Sigerson cup also had its share of controversies with both I.T Sligo and Queens ejected but again were reinstated after appeals.

“It’s a the case now that every game teams are investigating each other,” Says Weir. “UCD were looking into one or two of our players after we played them. There needs to be clearer guidelines so that on the day no questions can be asked about who can play and who can’t.”

Weir also calls for the edition of younger up and coming referees in order to combat favoritism. Still sore from the decision by Brian Galvin to send off one of his players in the opening match against CIT, Weir says “who sends off a player in the opening three minutes?

“It was a crazy decision by Galvin. We need new referees that don’t know these inter-county players like Galvin does. He was clearly laughing and joking with the likes of Aidan Walsh and and not penalising them as much. Give the younger referees a chance to develop and get rid of Galvin who doesn’t take this competition seriously.”

Weir has confirmed that he would like to stay on next year and that he was happy with his first stint into college hurling. Although the team will be losing the likes of Galway U-21 All-Star, Padraig Brehony, there are promising hurlers on the fresher squad that are chomping at the bit for Fitzgibbon hurling.

The year was unsatisfactory in terms of results but with lessons learned Weir is confident that DCU will see Fitzgibbon glory soon.

Thomas Blade

Image Credit: Sportsfile

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *